Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
Originally Posted by Brian Austin Whitney
Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
Remember when milli vanilli got blacklisted for lyo syncing.

The guy ended up killing himself from the backlash of it. He wasn't the only one to do that, and now today it's laughable.

The one way it still matters if a human wrote the song is if the artist builds his audience on the premise of, this is me talking to you, you relate, and you make me a star.

But if it's known upfront that it's ai, the listener makes choice to listen, not etc.

There will be many who will reject it if they know about it.

For other people that don't really get involved, they listen for recreation, they will not care

They already LIE TO THE FACES of people who buy tickets to see people sing live. Taylor does it. She does not say "please enjoy my recording as I dance to it" each show. That cat is WAY out of the bag. I assure you that if she had to disclose the tech used for each song (auto tune, A.I. processing, A.I. digital effects and EQ, sampled instruments, 10 million dollar mixing boards etc. etc.) not as many people would take out loans to buy tickets to the worship fest. But the REAL machine, the corporations and elite owner class, is not disclosing ANY of it. Guess what? They also are not SUING the guy exposing them because he has truth on his side. The irony is that A.I. enhanced software is catching the fakers! There is stuff much more powerful than Melodyne that they know they can't fake out. Even these fake photos have tells that A.I. has been finding. It will always be a race to catch the cheaters with the same tech they use to cheat. For me, what Taylor is doing is WAY more offensive than you making songs with A.I. But these anti A.I. people are often praising her shortcuts. But no shortcuts for little people!

I'm not using AI for anything more than to see what it can do as you stated you did in the op.

I'm not charging anyone, I'm not marketing myself as the artist of the music played.

Franky I don't need it, what it did was allow me to bring songs I was never going to do anything with anyway to life.

I don't think it's better than what I do myself, but it's quicker and easier. And a good reference. And better arrangements than what I could do all alone

I am not really understanding your response, as I was essentially agreeing with your point but your reply is written as if I didn't. i have 2300+ songs with no professional recordings. A.I. in my case (like yours it sounds) is allowing me to take the recordings I have (which are often just piano/vocal or maybe a few instruments and a drum machine) and upgrade them sonically to sound like pro demos. That is exactly what I need. I also genre switch and gender switch because a lot of the songs I wrote for our female singer to sing but her and my guitarist got divorced so w didn't get any of them recorded with her beyond practice tapes. So this lets me hear it with female vocals to see if it works. I can also go in, rewrite, adjust the arrangement and then have it produce dozens (or hundreds in one case) of examples to see if it catches the vibe I want. But in the end, I will take the songs that fit together best an us these demos to show the producer and vocalists what I am looking for. I am working on an album using a lot of our JPF Award winners over the 23 years we did the awards to put together my album. I can no longer play or sing live, so this is my only option. I have gotten all enthusiastic yes's so far from every artist I have asked). I won't even start on the final project until next summer when JPF turns 40. I figured that would be a great way to celebrate 40 years. I need to act because ALL of us are getting older. I think one key singer may have aged out sadly, so I don't want to lose any others. We had a 14 year old award winner I want to record with (she has been a Hollywood actress the past 25 years) but even she is turning 40 next year. No more time to waste.

A.I. has been the PERFECT tool for demos. I had no budget to pay for thousands of takes for a full band across many genres. Several of the key artists tour with major acts so their studio time will be quite limited and all my ducks have to be lined up for easy shooting. I also have a major producer who may be heading the project so his time can't be wasted. These are all great folks who have volunteered to help, but I have to respect their time and keep things straight forward. We are hoping to have a big concert to debut 10-12 of the songs next summer/fall. We also have a JPF Hall Of Fame ceremony planned. A.I. is an extension of my DAW and plug-ins which I am also using to sketch exactly what I want with each track. A.I. is good for demos, but there are a lot of details that must be worked out for each song. I also need to leave room for the instrumentalists to have room to add their magic to the mix.

Tech advances often leave people behind. It happens with every generation. It isn't an age thing, as I know guys in their 70s embracing the new tech, but people fear what they don't know or understand. There is no more or less "soul" in this than when any Synth or Sampler is used, or digital piano or fancy reverb etc. It is all artificial sound manipulation. There is zero difference between the tech naysayers use and this. Unless you are playing and singing acoustic only with no effects or EQ, you really have no legit argument that holds up against A.I. beyond you don't want to use it "because--reasons."


Brian Austin Whitney
Founder
Just Plain Folks
jpfolkspro@gmail.com
Skype: Brian Austin Whitney
Facebook: www.facebook.com/justplainfolks

"Don't sit around and wait for success to come to you... it doesn't know the way." -Brian Austin Whitney

"It's easier to be the bigger man when you actually are..." -Brian Austin Whitney

"Sometimes all you have to do to inspire humans to greatness is to give them a reason and opportunity to do something great." -Brian Austin Whitney