I'll offer a theory...

Over the years, this site has been allowed to devolve into a place where insults and acrimony were the main attraction.
Other sites that I visit knock that down quickly when it arises.

I know of two people who had a lot of informed knowledge to share and left because of the toxicity.
Additionally I suspect that many younger-than-the-median here, took a look and did not see much about songs here.
Additionally there is a lot of competition on facebook now. Anyone can start a dedicated page.
Additionally, in earlier years, there was the mistaken belief that these sites could be portals to get your song noticed by true players in the music industry. That may have happened a handful of times but rarely. As a result some of the attraction fed by that mistaken belief has not born out over the years. If anything got noticed, it was likely connected songwriters looking for ideas to lift.

However now that, people who have never spent a day of their lives actually in the music business arent calling people names and creating car wrecks...it has become quiet.

Imho...that is good.
It establishes a rational base to grow from.
Hopefully, doubters just need some extra time to see that they can engage here without being assaulted or witness to assaults.

If ultimately people dont come back here...getting them back here to watch arguments about politics etc is a certain death anyways.

Imho...what the site need now is some real good songs, that people want to be part of.

The preceding is worth what you paid for it Dave.

Marty