Originally Posted by John Lawrence Schick
As I mentioned before, my publisher makes us sign an agreement that we haven't used AI in any part of the songs we submit. I can't see the music supervisors of any major tv stations using this. They want music free of lawsuits. Although the low-budget stations may opt in for AI. It's definitely killing creativity. And it's more than just a tool to aid musicians. it's a system to do it all without real musicians. In the long run it's terrible for the Music Industry and creative songwriter/ composers. In it's present state, it needs more development. From what I've listened to, everything is quantized, even the vocal tracks. Sounds artificial - oh yeah, it is artificial.

John smile

John,

Believing the music/vocals to be "all" quantized is a basic misunderstanding of how the samples are created in the first place. The AI is trained on real audio. There is NO midi involved whatsoever in ANY part of the sample creation process, unlike AIVA, Magenta, and other tools. So it's a safe guess that some samples will sound quantized, such as EDM and Hip-Hop beats, but any older jazz or classical styles? Not so much. In fact, on their Discord Server, Udio users are complaining about how "unquantized" many of the samples are!

Indeed, I have been creating stems of some Udio tracks I wanted to work with, further, and after putting them on a timeline, I noticed many cases of BPM "drift" as well as notes within a given bar or two that are slightly ahead of and slightly behind the beat, and not in any perceivable pattern or (128th, 64th, 32nd, 16th) quantized measure.

I don't know exactly what Udio tracks you were listening to to form your opinion, but I notice no such quantization on the tracks I have been making, and if there was any hint of it I would know, having jaded ears from years of working in a DAW with both quantized and unquantized music.

As to "AI killing creativity"...

I am a creative songwriter and composer and I don't think "in the long run," as you say, that this is terrible. Nor do any of the songwriters that I talk to from my old Northern California stomping grounds, nor many of the recording artists I follow...such as Momus, one of the most prolific composers in the last few decades:




Don't you think it might be a little early to make such a sweeping epic pronouncement such as this?

Creativity comes down to making choices; that's all these tools do, is pair things down so we can make choices.

Creating from scratch, using just our brains and non-AI software will take a piece of music down a specific path that meets our intentions, with maybe (intentionally or not) a curve thrown here and there so our process isn't too predictable, unless that's the environment we want, when composing, creating, and finalizing audio tracks.

But the idea I am trying to convey here is, with normal composing methods, "intention" is in control of most every aspect of the music. With generative AI music, we are still in control over many of a music's aspects, and can figure out how to obtain what we need by writing in the prompt box those specific words that will elicit the music/vocals we want. Or as close to it as this fledgling AI can get us, as Udio is in Beta...

How is learning how to tell AI how to fulfill an intention anything other than a creative act?

Maybe a different kind of creativity, but "understand our intention" figures prominently in both normative compositional methods and AI ones.

Creativity and "surprise" share a nice bit of overlap in their Venn Diagram. Creating music with AI gets folks back in touch with their "inner child," cuz it feels like magic, and what it outputs is often in the "happy surprise" category of something not quite expected, but good, nevertheless. Indeed, I have witness this in recent days from JPFers here, as they use Udio.

I welcome the democratization of the art making experience. Maybe crime will go down or at least some people will lead less boring lives. There are all kinds of people in this world. Maybe some of them just want an alternative to Prime Video and discover they can "create" exactly the KIND of music they hear in their head, with Udio. I guess I am a little disappointed that you can't imagine that this AI could be of any use for anyone.

I am not asking you to like music AI in any of its forms. You make Library Music, and with the advent of Udio, of course you are not going to like something that might, someday, mean your income slows down.

AI is nearing "singularity" proportions. It is getting better and better, faster and faster. Soon enough, whatever drawbacks you yourself are hearing in it--they will be gone. Udio has only been around two weeks or so.

There are indeed a LOT of professionals justifiably threatened by the advent of AI, and we all know it is not going away, and no one embraces adaptation, except maybe the youngest among us.

It's okay to feel threatened by AI and it's drawbacks/negatives while still recognizing its potential benefit for mankind.

Music creation AI tools like Udio.com can be powerful additions to the creative process, but it's critical to use them with intention and awareness. By embracing them as collaborators rather than replacements, musicians can navigate the potential risks and explore exciting new sonic territories. And non-musicians who don't care to become musicians? Perfect tool for them...


Mike

*******************************************************************************************

Here's a summary of my thoughts...

The impact of music creation AI tools like Udio.com on the creative process is complex and has both potential benefits and risks:

Potential Benefits:

Democratization of Music Creation: AI tools can lower the barrier to entry for music creation.

They provide an accessible way for non-musicians to explore their creativity and make music that was previously out of their reach.
Inspiration and Experimentation: For experienced musicians, AI can serve as a source of inspiration, pushing them outside their comfort zones with unexpected chord progressions, melodies, or rhythmic patterns. It opens up new ways to experiment.
Efficiency and Workflow: AI tools can assist with technical tasks like generating chord progressions, drum patterns, or basic arrangements, saving time and effort for musicians.

Potential Risks:

Over-reliance and Homogenization: If musicians become over-reliant on AI tools, there's a risk that it could lead to a lack of originality and a homogenization of sound. Music may start to sound formulaic and lose its unique, human touch.
Devaluing Skill and Artistry: The ease with which AI tools can generate music might lead to a devaluation of the skills and artistry musicians develop through years of practice and dedication.
Ethical Concerns and Copyright: The use of AI-generated music raises questions of ownership, copyright, and potential use of existing musical material without proper attribution.

Mitigating Risks and Finding Balance

The key to harnessing the power of AI in music creation lies in finding a balance:

Treat AI as a Tool, Not a Master: Use AI tools as a complement to your creativity, not a replacement for it.

Employ them to spark ideas, explore possibilities, but always infuse your work with your own unique voice and artistry.
Develop Musical Skills: Continue to hone your musical skills, understanding theory, and learning instruments. This makes your collaborations with AI more meaningful and keeps you in control of the creative direction.
Ethical Usage: Be mindful of potential copyright issues when working with AI-generated music.

Seek transparent tools that clearly define the ownership and licensing terms.

Last edited by Michael Zaneski; 04/22/24 06:30 PM.

Fate doesn't hang on a wrong or right choice
Fortune depends on the tone of your voice

-The Divine Comedy (Neil Hannon)
from the song "Songs of Love"
from the album "Casanova" (1996)