Originally Posted by John Lawrence Schick
Originally Posted by Sunset Poet
Originally Posted by John Lawrence Schick
It doesn't matter. I know I did it. The bottom-line is "intent". We've all been influenced by others. And that's a good thing. Otherwise, we'd all still be writing chants. Ubio is knowingly using others' work.

John

When you write a song, if you can trace the antecedents (influences) in your mind...then you are "using other's work" to arrive at your work.
A strong if not bullet-proof case can be made that your work would never have been written without the influences.
You heard them, they registered in your brain and subconscious and left impressions that remain.
That's comparable to assembling an algorithm.

What will matter is the actual comparison of your work to the "influencing" work.
If it is dead on, and you had access, there is a problem for you.
If it is not dead on, and you had access, there is no problem or less of a problem for you.

Udio will make the same argument, and it is a viable point of view.
Alleging theft is not proving theft by legal definitions.

Study up on the "Taurus" decision.
Led Zep won the case.
I personally dont think that they should have.
But they did.

Ps...sorry, I wanted to drop out but you keep repeating something that ignores too much fact to let go. I'll try again

Dom, you're having trouble telling the difference between an apple and an orange. In the process of leaning music theory and composition, we study those that came before us. And it’s not only in music, but in all things, man builds on previous knowledge to create something new. Otherwise, we’d still be living in caves. Your analogy doesn’t hold water.

Okay, I’m leaving this thread. You just chased another person off Dom… Only kidding. laugh

John smile

Yeah it's all learned borrowed stolen JS bach may be only one who can otherwise

I just envision one of these so songs and nobody crediting me for my role, instead talking about what the ai did.

Like it makes us all equal

I already see where it still pays to be pretty good at what you do.

Even in something as simple as knowing what is good and bad when u hear it

Last edited by Fdemetrio; 04/17/24 01:51 PM.