Not quite what you were arguing LOL, but let's not get into that. I think your TV analogy is spot on - "It's like watching a TV show and saying the script dont, matter" - although I'd say the melody is even more important, or, if you're the Rolling Stones, and pretty much only if you're the Rolling Stones, a killer riff. A really good production is vital, but if you don't start with something worthwhile, it's like getting a Michelin starred chef to prepare a turd. It'll probably look better than your mom's apple pie but I know which one will have you coming back for seconds.