The claim that any musician is in the band in a box is misleading. It's a tiny sampling of his work. He didnt play every riff and every guitar part in every key, or to accomodate every chord change. He played it one way on a recording, and then the algorithm then contorts that sample to give the illusion he is playing for you.

It would be the same as say isolotaing eric claptons guitar solo from a live show or a recording, and then taking that solo and putting it into a daw, and then using a pitch change to change the key.

But, I think the advantage of it is for somebody who doesn t play anything, or really know much about music. However, then they cant really use band in the box effectively.

Its weird a catch 22. Its something only musicians can really make work, yet a musician understands what it sounds like. At the same time, it's FOR people who are not musicians or can not play multiple instruments.

Without playing anything, somebody who understands music, is still going to do better with BIAB than somebody who doesnt.

Last edited by Bugsey; 06/26/13 03:30 PM.