Originally Posted by Mike Dunbar
Magne, the very defitinion of "republic" would already dismiss anarchist. I was an anarchist...I know. LOL.


Well, there you go. The German philosopher Kant defined these terms back in the day as follows:

Anarchy is law and freedom without violence
Despotism is law and violence without freedom
Barbarism is violence without freedom and law
Republic is violence with freedom and law

So anarchy is not really chaotic, it's more a society based around naturally formed groupings with totally free individuals. Pretty much like the lyric to "Imagine". It's not a place sustained by violence, though, so not really republican, allthough I'd bet some could do without the violence, hence the "wet dream" comment.

Originally Posted by Mike Dunbar
Well, Lennon must have been a Marxist, I've heard all my life about Marx and Lennon. I wonder if Groucho was a Lennonist?


I heard Lennon was the biggest Elvis fan in the Beatles. So maybe more like an Elvisist.

But sometimes people even get what they are about themselves, wrong. These things are not really simple, and can be defined in whatever direction you want. We collect a lot of rubbish ideas from the everyday trash can to form our opinions and orientations.

Say, the 60'ies Hippies said they were all about communities ect, but they only wanted to follow their own drift. There are paradoxes built into those political orientations.

If you are a democrat, you need to force freedom onto people who doesn't want it or can handle it. If you are a republican, you need to take freedom away to secure a neccesary community to support the state.

There's just no way to win.

But singing about anarchy, where the ideal is law and order without violence is a pretty safe bet from an artistic point of view.

It makes the artist look great. Rule no 1 in songwriting :-)