I will say at this point the person in question is a part of NARAS and is a voting member of the Grammys. He is also a regional judge of American Idol. And as I said he has managed platinum bands before (not sure if he is currently).
I have also found recent online testimony of someone who got a very similar proposal and took advantage of it with good success.

Please understand that there are 5 of us in the band and we all have to come to some kind of consensus.

I am trying to gather as much info as possible. Including these comments and advice by you guys.

I also have to keep in mind that at this point it would be doubtful that anyone would break from the pack (and say anything but run from this situation) especially with only the annonymous info I have provided. It is hard to get the full scoop when I don't name names. As a last stitch effort I may make names public before we commit to anything.