Hi Nat,

It looks like I'm in the minority here, so please take my comments as one person's opinion. This song really didn't do much for me. (Maybe you just spoiled me with "When You Smile" smile ) One thing that bothered me was that about half way through I began to notice that the melody appeared to simply follow the chord progression throughout. So I guess I'd say that my ear wanted to hear a little more variation in that regard - where the melody was not just hugging the chords. Musically, it was very interesting to me. I agree with the other posts in that I believe you have a good ear for arranging the parts of a song to work together -- probably your good instinct that was mentioned earlier. As far as the lyrics go, I think they might be a little dark and obscure for the pop market you mention. There's a complicated problem described, and no resolution, or happy ending, for example. It's just not the kind of lyric I hear on popular music (and that's not a bad thing... unless you want to pitch this song as pop).

All that said, I agree that it's obvious you have lots of talent. I'm just questioning if this song is where it needs to be to meet the objectives you've stated for it. To me you seem to have your own unique songwriting style, and lots of folks have posted to suggest you continue to cultivate that (and I agree!). In my nonprofessional opinion (with virtually no experience to back it up), though, the pop market isn't looking for artists or songwriters who are trying to offer something new and fresh. They want tried and true formulas that they think will sell based on past successes.

Again, please take my comments with a grain of salt. I am but one person with absolutely no experience in the industry you're looking to sell to. So I could be way off base. smile Best of luck with this.


Rob's Music is also on SoundCloud