I know that even though the equipment is important, it also has a lot to do with confidence and knowledge of the mic setup.
I know in the few times I was blitzed enough in a bar to do a karaoke song, feeling loose with that mic and having a knowledge in what I was singing had everything to do from a standing O to a blank stare.
In the internet medium, the moment does'nt seem to be captured as much.
Maybe technology can try to modify or imitate that.
But like everything else, it is knowledge and confidence with ones recording setup.
Some feel confidence with primitive methods to where others need all kinds of effects.
I guess it depends on our own distictive idea in what makes a valid vocal representation.