I just got back from taking my 17-year-old daughter to "Hairspray". There is some very clever writing in this musical- very funny. The only problem I had was John Travolta. They should have cast a woman because I didn't believe him for a minute. The young actress was very good though. We should tackle a musical some time- would be fun.


Now that I have heard all the takes on this, here is my observation" 1. they were all so different, it wouldn't have mattered had I listened to them before- except maybe Louis- I think he and I may have had a similar take on these lyrics.

Graham, you cheated by substituting your own lyrics but you are forgiven because you are 12000 miles away and you probably don't have Pickerel or Checkerberries down under anyway. Do you write to a track or do you write and add tracks later? I suspect you may be writing to pre existing tracks or to Band-in-the-box created tracks. I play harmonica and I will try to add that to my next song. Do you play "cross harp"- that is: use a G harp in the song of C for instance? It you haven't tried that yet, you will be amazed at how blusey the song will sound because it is easy to bend notes when you draw rather than blow.

Vanessa, you are a trooper for doing the song extemporaneously and a Capella. I would never try that! You have a nice sense of melody and fortunately, a good voice. I could hear your kid(s) in the background.

Scott, the song was working pretty well. I was hoping that both you and Louis would do the whole thing- especially to see if you detected the bridge that was hiding in the verse.

Rick, your treatment is one I would have never thought of. The only place where I thought the treatment "ran over" the lyrics is the part- I have forgotten, am forgot. It seems like that has to be delivered carefully because it is basically the heart of the poem.

Michael. About 15 years ago when I was writing a lot of kids songs, I took the poem from Wind in the Willows and turned it into a song and it turned out very well I think. I thought of pitching it to Disney. Other than that song, I don't recall ever trying to put music to old poems until "Long Ago". If you haven't read the book, the poem goes like this:

`DUCKS' DITTY.'
All along the backwater,
Through the rushes tall,
Ducks are a-dabbling,
Up tails all!

Ducks' tails, drakes' tails,
Yellow feet a-quiver,
Yellow bills all out of sight
Busy in the river!

Slushy green undergrowth
Where the roach swim--
Here we keep our larder,
Cool and full and dim.

Everyone for what he likes!
WE like to be
Heads down, tails up,
Dabbling free!

High in the blue above
Swifts whirl and call--
WE are down a-dabbling
Up tails all!

I barely changed a word- just repeated "Up tails all" with different harmonies.

We could make this the next challenge I guess cause I wouldn't have to do any work but if someone has an idea for a "musical" challenge, I am game. How about we take a scene from a popular movie and write a situational song as if we were writing a musical.



"Imagination is more important than knowledge." - Albert Einstein