I don't know anything about publishing since I am still in my learning stages.
Maybe just looking at a site is'nt enough indication.
But I tapped that atlantic-artist link at the start of the post.
I was able to get the page super fast on dial-up, where even with my own small homesite takes about ten to fifteen seconds for the page to load up.
That pop site speed may indicate that the site could have been put up by a scammer or phisher.
Though I don't want to falsely accuse, I would be checking and rechecking any source I can get my hands on to find out the legitamacy.

There seems to be something fishy, right down to the borrowing of the Atlantic name.

Is'nt there a way through these reputable publishing organizations (ASCAP, BMI, etc.) where the legitemacy these type of companies can be found out?

They probably could'nt keep up with them.
There are ISP's where the legitemacy of a business can be found out.

I would'nt mess around with this unless I knew for dead certain.
I'm going to be looking through different search systems.

Matt