Hey Andy,
I can understand the need for critique. I have a wonderful mentor who is constantly keeping me on my toes! I don't see anything wrong with celebrating people's creativity, either (as in a folk song circle where people just enjoy the process of playing and listening).
I've lived with enough "critics" over the years and have no desire to put my "children" in such a vulnerable position. Each person's thoughts and ideas on what makes a good song is different. If I listened to each one and tried to incorporate what they have to say into what I'm doing, I'd go crazy. I do however, think that looking at what a song is trying to say and how long it takes to say it is a valuable thing. I've seen the results of what can happen when critiques are perceived as personal attacks, and have seen artists do this to each other. I guess it has just left a bad taste in my mouth.
While I value constructive criticism, I think it has to be done in an atmosphere of trust on the part of those doing criticizing with the person who's work is being criticized. The idea is help, not hurt the artist, and we, as artists are very vulnerable to criticism. It's the nature of the beast!
- Donna

------------------
http://donnaklein.com