Ritt,

I understand the POV of the song and for what it's worth, the message is thought provoking. I used to think this way too but I've come to the conclusion that this thinking is wrong.

Given the shameful history of the way the US has treated those who did not fit a certain profile, if you will, it's difficult for me to reconcile the thoughts that go into a song like this.

You don't subjugate an entire race of people for 300 or more years then one day decide everything's okay and NOW we're all equal. It just doesn't work that way. You've got centuries of a group of people being told they are useless, they are less than human, being lynched and pretty much anything you can think of that could dennegrate a person. It's just not a simple thing to undo. It takes generations but I think the fact that there has been an emerging black middle class over the past 20-30 years, is evidence that we are finally starting to get it right after all this time.

Are those of us white people living today responsible for most of this? Most of us are not but I can guarantee you that there are plenty of whites left who played (or still play) a role in the ugliness. They have only gone underground because enough of the good white people finally stood up and said, "enough." Either way, we are stuck with the end result of the crimes committed by those who came before us. Most of us are not to blame but we cannot dismiss the effects of what has been done in the past.

Blacks in the US were robbed of their culture, so they took what they were allowed to have and created their own. Things like BET, Black Miss America, the NAACP are a celebration of the culture they passed on down through generations of servitude and subjugation. The fact that they were able to turn so much ugliness into many positives is a tribute to their fortitude.

All this does not come without problems. The black community still struggles with poverty, crime, unwed motherhood any many other problems in numbers that are disproportinate to their population. But the whites who point to these things as evidence that they are not making the most of the opportunities, are missing the larger point.

Most of the opportunities available to blacks today have only been available for a relatively short amount of time. In the meantime, there is the mindset that has been ingrained in them for centuries. As I said, it doesn't change overnight. This doesn't mean that blacks don't have diversity of opinion. They have a lot more than most of us recognize. The mindset of which I speak is the one engrained by the white culture under which they have been subjected.

Us whites today (again, most of us are not guilty of what was done) want to bury our heads in the sand and pretend that it should all be okay now. After all, we (most of us at least) aren't doing anything to hold anybody down right? Why don't "they" act like us and do their best according to our standards? I suspect that it's because it was "our" standards that told them that they were no good and didn't give them a chance to assimilate into our culture. As a result, one can hardly blame them for carving out a culture of their own. Had our predecessors been inclusive from the beginning, I doubt that we'd be having this conversation today.

The point is that blacks have struggled to gain some sense of pride when they were told for so long that they were useless. They still have a cultural mindset to overcome and maybe, just maybe, having these few little things that are just theirs that they don't have to share, helps the healing process along the way.

Things are changing for the better but it's still going to take time. The best we whites can do is be patient and watch blacks come into their own. They have shown that they know how to overcome. Let's not get in their way but if they need a little help along the way, I don't think it hurts us to do this as well.

It's for the reasons above that I cannot enjoy these lyrics though the message is straightforward and conversational (good lyrical qualities). I don't think we need all this political correctness crap and we certainly have become a society of the offended. If your song was about that, I'd be right with you.

[This message has been edited by Buzz Grudge (edited 06-29-2004).]


Van Borden
a.k.a. Buzz Grudge