John-

I get it now about no ring on the hand. I like it - it makes sense. Considering that, I don't know if I'd change it. It kind of pulls the song together for me. I didn't get it first time through, but now I kind of feel like I get the song more. So . . . I don't know.

A counter melody is an independent melodic line that is different than the main melody and intertwines with it. So, instead of singing the same melodic shape in the same rhythmic pattern a third above (one example of harmony), you might be singing a second line with a similar melodic shape and a different rhythmic pattern. Just an idea.