Wow! This thread really shocked me. I am amazed that somebody made a device to correct singing pitch, and that people actually use it. Doesn't it make more sense to take some voice lessons if you have pitch problems? I mean, if a person can't reach the high notes, he could sing in a key that is within his range, or do some vocal exercises to increase his range so those notes are not too high anymore, or make sure he gets enough extra breath to support his voice before he goes for those notes.

Don't we have built-in pitch correctors, called ears? They are amazing devices, built right into our heads. If a singer isn't in the habit of really paying attention to whether she's on pitch or not, wouldn't it make sense for her to practice that and get good at listening while she sings?

I'm just surprised at the lack of musicianship involved in using a machine to correct vocal pitch. I wonder if people would want to listen to someone play, for example, a saxophone, if the musician had to play through a machine in order to stay on pitch.

I personally would not want to use a machine instead of really learning to sing well.

I guess this all sounds pretty arrogant on my part. Charlie, Larry, and Pat, I apologize for that. I don't mean to be a jerk, I am just really shocked. Maybe I just don't understand how the device is used--I'm curious (and kind of nervous) to see what you say to this.

With respect--Jean