Man, this is gonna be tough, but here goes anyway.
Brian: "INXS hasn't been on the radio/in the news/on tour because MH is dead and that was the end of the band."
WRONG.
Whitesides: "INXS has been making a go of touring for the last several years with several singers. One was Terence Trent D'arby."
FACT: They did
a single date with Jimmy Barnes in 1998 in Melbourne, and
a single date with Terence Trent D'arby in 1999 to open the Olympic Stadium in Sydney.
Hardly what Jody claims they did before Stevens was asked to join, and
FACT: Jon Stevens started doing dates and the "Just For Kicks" tour with them in 2000, according to
INXS.com , leaving in November 2003.
So Brian, you're simply factually ignorant on that matter.
Stevens and INXS
did write
ONE song that got placed on a rugby video-game.
So Brian, you're just plain WRONG.
They
HAD a new lead singer, that worked for their sound.
They toured the U.S., South America, Europe, and other locales with Jon Stevens. And they and he sounded like the INXS that their fans and even casual listeners remembered. I testify to that.
Why they stalled doing a record with Stevens is beyond me. But my guess is that he couldn't deliver lyrics that Andrew found palatable, and wanted more influence in the sound and direction of the band than they were willing to give him.
It certainly wasn't because he didn't sound or look 'right' for the gig!
Brian: "I have also seen/heard you sing live twice and heard you on recordings."
WRONG again.
You heard me sing ONCE, I didn't perform in Tempe. I was there to check YOU out.
The CD I gave you doesn't show the entire breadth of my vocal ability, but I DO recommend you go to the 40LOVE link to hear me demoing a James Brown sound ("Thing4U") and an Ian Astbury vibe ("The Samantha Pleas"), and to the EdX link to hear me demoing an MH feel ("DoWhatYouGotta"), if yer really that all uprighteously perturbed about my comments and dismissive of my chops, pal.
It's all part of my "...please find something better to do with your life, like work on your own music instead" program that you recommended.
Brian: "Are you actually suggesting that you're in the same league talent wise as any of those vocalists/performers?"
Yeah, I am.
What you and the roomful in Encinitas heard, Brian, was me singing and playing an introspective, nuanced, melancholy ORIGINAL ROCK SONG. The vocal delivery was apropos to the lyric theme. No caterwauling oversinging or warbling unrestrained vibrato or spotlight-posing there (despite the two large coffees, man, they make yer mouth tacky!).
What you and that roomful
didn't hear was me auditioning for INXS by singing Eagles or Living Colour or Queen or the Clash (how much sense does
that make?), because that wasn't what I was there to do.
The roomful seemed to like my performance quite alot, AIR. Their response after the party was uniformly positive, and NO, I'm not ascribing that to the jovial JPF showcase conviviality. They loved it. You really oughta go back and watch the tape again.
Speaking of 'the tape',
Brian: "In the case of Ed, I have seen him in Phoenix and San Diego performing live and heard his CD. If he evaluated that he was talented enough to deserve a legit shot at fronting that band, then it's inconceivable that he could feel that these folks aren't deserving, unless he feels his talent is superior. I can't believe he thinks that for real. I have the video tapes of him performing."
That sounds like a threat, pal. Go ahead, I dare ya. I
double-dog dare ya! Put it up, if that's what you think think will 'put that uppity nitwit' back in his place.
Put it up and link to it from this thread.
Pull back the curtain and expose me for the 'over-confident buffoon' you seem to be calling me. Anytime, anyplace.
So back to the circus and the clowns...Did any of the people axed by INXS deserve to be there based on their vocal and stage talent?
In a word, no. They weren't "right for [their] band, INXS." So why waste everybody's time when it should've been apparent from the get-go?
Brian, I can see why Bob Young continually questions your reading and comprehension skills, 'cause you blew right by the part where I said "that I was stunned by
some of the..." (emphasis added). Not 'all of the'. Glasses, maybe?
Five people shoulda been picked to start this circus. Ty, Jordis, Marty, Mig, and somebody else.
And they shoulda all been singing all-INXS, all-the-time, unless the band is planning on putting "Take It Easy" or "Layla" or "Blister in the Sun" or "Rock The Casbah" into the setlist for the tour. 'Cause how well you do Bob Marley says zip about one's ability to sing "Need You Tonight".
Which brings up the inclusion of women.
Does anybody really think that the band is gonna transpose almost thirty years of repertoire up a whole step or minor third, and strain their ability to do the backing vox to accomodate a woman???
It was just another way to call marks to the circus.
It's a specialist job. There's a history, a vibe, and a sound that are part and parcel of their success. It's not a Broadway production of "The Producers", where Jason Alexander or Alexandra Paul or Paul Shaffer can be scheduled to take over for Matt Broderick, and the joint STILL sells out!
Was there a Led Zeppelin without Plant? A Beatles without John or George or Ringo? A Queen without Freddie Mercury (jury will remain out on that one)?
Brian, you talk about "new palette" and "new direction" for INXS. So do they have one all picked out? Are the songs gonna be written by the winner after the coronation like the CBS promos claim?
I really doubt it, because with the entire album tracked by the band beforehand, waiting only for the lyrics to be written and lead vox to be dropped on before their scheduled world tour later
THIS YEAR,
it's putting a lot of eggs in one basket, and putting
WAY too much on whomever gets the job.
Andrew and Jon And Kirk have already written the lyrics, bet on it, making the claim that "the winner will write the songs" a lie, and the show fraudulent in that respect.
New direction?
Well in INXS' case it oughta come with a new name.
Mig will win. Man, I'm glad the poseur-hack Brandon who sang sharp the whole song tonight is gone!
Jon Stevens oughta still be the frontman.
Now get cracking on that video, Brian, I'm anxious to see it!
Thank you for your patience, dear reader.
[This message has been edited by ed323 (edited 08-11-2005).]