Originally Posted by John Lawrence Schick
Originally Posted by Michael Zaneski
Originally Posted by John Lawrence Schick
I’ve always believed that music should be composed from the heart. Robotic, unemotional music will never cut it with me.

John

I'm w/Marty, here, John.

The story of Sir John Gielgud's interaction with Dustin Hoffman on the set of "Marathon Man" has become a legendary tale in Hollywood lore.

During the filming of a scene where Hoffman's character is supposed to look exhausted, Hoffman reportedly stayed up all night to achieve the desired disheveled appearance. Gielgud, renowned for his classical acting training and professionalism, observed Hoffman's method and famously quipped, "Why not try acting, dear boy? It's much easier."

I mention this to remind you, John, that emotions can be faked, and the end result can be we, the audience, feel via empathy, those emotions, whether real or faked. Two great actors: one fakes the emotion (Gielgud), one experiences it and shares it (Hoffman), both can evoke a range of emotions in an audience.

If one wants emotional music, one can prompt for it in various ways, in Udio.

But I apologize...I never realized I have such an "inner salesman" in me. Why do I need you to be interested in Udio? I don't know. If you are comfortable with how you create, why try anything new or different? But DON'T NOT try it cuz you think all the results will be lacking emotion. The emotions are in US. Some machines can emulate stronger emotions than some of the people I know, LOL!

Of course, when I mention emotions and the heart of the composer, I mean real emotions. And no, I don't think any AI application will feel emotion. I'm afraid this new udio thing will give users a false sense of accomplishment. Nothing better than the real thing - that comes with hard work.

John smile

John, that's a lot to unpack.

I feel a hundred things when you say that.

Maybe some people feel a false sense of accomplishment, then the scenerio plays out, and they realize they made a number of decisions that was in (at least) some small way, creativity, maybe with a little "c" --and they continue on with their life...

Others may be just happy to have found a way to "get" muisic they like? By directly prompting for it?

Some may feel FULL ON delusions of grandeur, but I imagine in most cases these were just big delusions-of-grandeur cases just waiting to happen.

Yes, John, everybody should toil and slave over their work so it FEELS like they made something, they should all take 4 years of training and study with Nadia Boulanger, and work and work...HOW DARE they think that what they are doing is making music?!?!?!

Okay, yes, sarcasm...SORRY...but GEEEEZ!

Maybe, just maybe...SOME folks are adults and know they are not COMPLETE musicians like you, and that's exactly why they want to use this kind of AI!

Last edited by Michael Zaneski; 04/15/24 03:42 PM.

Fate doesn't hang on a wrong or right choice
Fortune depends on the tone of your voice

-The Divine Comedy (Neil Hannon)
from the song "Songs of Love"
from the album "Casanova" (1996)