Seven seconds of thought and;
Ask them to 'cover' the Song and let you hear their product.
That doesn't solve your problem of decision-making but gives you some possible criteria for making a decision.
I'm betting someone will do a better job than others.
I had CMT, Country Music Television, back when the world was young and noticed Diane Warren had about three artists all doing one of her Songs, the same Song, plus a couple other artists doing other Songs of hers, all at the same time. I think there were five. They each had one 'hit' playing. Diane had five.
Aerosmith was one of the three same-Song 'coverers, crossing over to the Pop market.
It may still be a tough decision to make; but it might 'weed out' the 'lesser' products and find the 'gold' one.
Enjoy your wonderful dilemma.
Oh, and...do it again! And again. Be prepared to do it again. One success may bring others or the not-selected ones coming back looking for more.

Last edited by Gary E. Andrews; 11/10/23 11:26 AM.

There will always be another song to be written. Someone will write it. Why not you? www.garyeandrews.com