Good idea Brian. What happened in this scenario, you had a drummer, who said ok, i wanna try to make a song, so im gonna record three sections of drums. The job of the others was to build on it. I think the drummer, hence this guy did a great job, cause obviously the sections were enhanced by the bass player, then the guitarist. But without the sections, it would have no structure.

It was more a jam track, he never mentioned that the singer wrote the words or melody, i guess he assumed we knew that. Just as the bassist creates a melody, so too does the singer. I dont think anybody cares about the quality of the lyric in this case, especially when its treated as an after thought, and was probably very hard for somebody to write lyrics that way.

I didnt think either of the singers was very good either, but remember here, were talking 5 dollars. The last thing on this guys mind was the quality of the lyric, i guess he expected a halfway decent melody

Meh, but the drums bass and guitar were great, and could easily be a track used for something.

Im not sure if he got their agreements signed, he knew he wasn't writing a masterpiece, starting on drums.

I see no reason why this couldn't be done and done much better.

This type of top off is done all the time, with one difference, its not starting with a drummer, its somebody who composes music.

But id say it shows the potential of working with other musicians. pay them 25 bucks and im sure youd get much better returns.

And if you write a lyric only, what else were you going to do with it?

Not a great song, but shows what can be done when you have something strong to start off with.

Ive never seen people so cheap about 5 dollars. Where is the loss in what this guy did? and he increased his youtube hits.

Not bad.

Last edited by Fdemetrio; 03/29/21 11:44 AM.