Originally Posted by Deej56
Fdemetrio,

First off, a great title/hook. Totally catches the eye and makes it a must listen. Really like the piano, Springsteen like feel; lovely melody and solid vocal. And the production touches are nuanced and engaging. I actually think the arrangement is pretty solid.

Lyrically, a few nits . . . at least for me, recognizing it’s all somewhat subjective . . . but for what it’s worth . . . The “just eating some popcorn” line for me doesn’t work. I get where you are going with it, but the lines preceding and following aren’t consistent with that feel (if in fact I am getting what you intended). “Havoc,” “traffic,” and “damning his luck” doesn’t seem to jibe with “eating some popcorn” (which suggests he's sitting back enjoying what's going on). I think an opportunity to change that line, and as it isn’t dependent on rhyme scheme, you have some lattitude to do so.

I like the imagery and the rhyme scheme of the second verse, but I’m wondering if the line “on the brick of this hood” works. First, in “hood” I think you mean the slang “the hood,” but there’s really nothing that sets that up, so on first listen I thought you mean the hood of a car, which of course makes no sense. I’d opt to replace “of this hood” (three syllables) with “neighborhood” (also three syllables, so it shouldn’t mess with the pace and feel of the melody), and then precede that with something like “through the streets of our neighborhood”. Though I think you can do better than “the streets”. I do like the idea of “our” neighborhood though, as it establishes a connection between the singer and Rosie through community.

Very, very good song—one of my favorites from you. My suggestions above are just that. It stands very solid as is, but offering up a different perspective in spots for you to think about. I always find it helpful even if to validate my thought process on a tune. So in that spirit, I hope the above it useful to some degree.

All my best,

Deej


Thanks Dee. I see your nits, could be room for improvement. As I see it's setting the scene of where Juan lives, how humdrum and boring his life is, with not alot of hope. Sitting on a fire escape watching the cars go by, while eating popcorn is what he does to fill his time. I guess it does depend what your vision of where he is. They say to leave some room for the listener to decide for themselves instead of trying to paint it exactly... but
I think the "hood" is established, who sits on a fire escape in the suburbs? Popcorn... a cheap snack, we eat when bored too...

I was envisioning it from the pov of two people living in apartment complex..I see this one spot often and start wondering who is thinking what as they walk around.

Who does the laundry on a clothesline any more but poorer people? needing a GED equivalent tells you that hes not very qualified to do much, which is probably why he's living there in the first place.

I think it works, but I could try to tweak it a bit. Thanks for the nice comments and good ears!

Last edited by Fdemetrio; 02/05/20 11:50 AM.