JPF Home Page Forums Thread Like Summary - Starlit Night(Suno)

I did an experiment with SUNO.

I uploaded an audio, a simple strumming on my ukulele.
Strumming in the key of A, 57 sec. that goes like this:
Section A: 8 bars in 4/4
A / /A /E /D / /E /A /
Section B: 8 bars in 4/4
D /A /D /E /D /A /G /E /
Repeat Section A: 8 bars in 4/4
A / /A /E /D / /E /A /_

Link to listen: https://suno.com/song/a1772089-9310-4097-ab36-0dbb42966b07
The only thing I did is the 57 seconds of strumming with my ukulele.

The result is a 3 minutes song.
Link to listen: https://suno.com/song/8f802602-f2a8-45bd-bfd4-183fad7f3b20

Generated lyrics by Suno:
Title: Starlit Night
Style of music: acoustic

[Verse]
Up above the moon shines bright
Twinkling stars in the sky
City lights fade to night
Dancing shadows passing by

[Verse 2]
Whispers in the cool night air
Echoes of a distant song
Underneath the dreamy glare
Holding on all night long

[Chorus]
Starlit night oh starlit night
Warm and glowing magic light
Starlit night oh starlit night
Take me on a flight so high

[Verse 3]
Waves are crashing on the shore
Silver trails across the sand
Moments lost forevermore
Take my heart and hold my hand

[Bridge]
Lonely lovers' lullaby
Silver dreams in endless sky
Wish upon a star
Don't sigh
Catch a glimpse before they die

[Chorus]
Starlit night oh starlit night
Warm and glowing magic light
Starlit night oh starlit night
Take me on a flight so high

My take on this experiment:

Nice voice: mix of Michael Buble and Ed Sheeran
Nice melody and rhythm. In A major and BPM: 118
Good contrast between sections.
I like the structure:
verse, verse, chorus, verse, bridge (twice), chorus,
interlude and a solo to finish.
Lyrics: I like the chorus and the bridge.
The verses are soso...

Overall, it's fine but what I love to do is to compose melodies.
I don't want AI to compose melodies for me.

I think it's a fine tool for lyricists only.
Suno should produce music sheets...

I agree. Lyricist benefit most from this right now. I'm waiting for it to be able to accept my melodies, my riffs
And then sing it too. At that point it will ai doing the arranging. Like band in a box does. But it's an opportunity to learn how to write lyrics, too