Who's Online
30 registered (Z. Mulls, Barry David Butler, Travis david, Alek, ben willis, Calvin, 9 invisible) and 225 anonymous users online.
Shout Box

What's Going On
Top Posters
26755
"Tampa Stan" Good
16289
Brian Austin Whitney
13618
Graham Henderson
13421
Calvin
11806
Bobbie Gallup
10861
Scott Campbell
10690
Richard G Blum
10244
Jean Bullock
10240
Kaley Willow
9175
Al David
8878
Joice Marie
8632
Kevin Emmrich
8389
Corky Bernard
8302
Tricia Baker
8203
Mike Dunbar
8077
BIG JIM MERRILEES
8058
John Voorpostel
7782
Mike Caro Substudio
7389
glynda
7355
Corey
7185
Johnny Daubert
6894
Beth G. Williams
6846
couchgrouch
6278
Ben Burton
6190
Bill Robinson
6178
Joe Wrabek
6175
Wyman Lloyd
5927
Mark Kaufman
5683
Mackie H.
5526
Linda Adams
5484
Louis
5161
Lynn Orloff
4998
Robert Pickens
4842
ben willis
4809
Derek Hines
4758
Douglas Murphy
4726
Everett Adams
4691
Janice Hopkins
4663
Colin Ward
4612
Emily Sanders
4540
Ray E. Strode
4528
Blake Hill
4430
Anthony Torres
4426
Moker Jarrett
4372
Bob Young
4285
Michael Borges
4179
bailey bridges
4178
John Lawrence Schick
4172
Cindy Miller
4153
KimberlyinNC
4109
Bob Cushing
4053
niteshift
3900
Joanne Lurgio
3817
Ricki E. Bellos
3635
DonnaMarilyn
3622
Marc Barnette
3618
Samuel Harris
3565
Tom Shea
3463
John W. Selleck
3414
Dave Rice
3390
the songcabinet
3346
Jody Whitesides
3301
Michele Howlett
3279
Bill Cooper
3276
WriterTomYeager
3262
Little_stevie_b
3262
Caroline
3258
Paul T Wentworth
3190
Kristi McKeever
3109
Dottie
3101
Michael Zaneski
3087
Greg C. Brown
3065
Michael James Moore
3027
Skip Johnson
3007
Pam Hurley
2922
John Hoffman
2918
Sharon Longworth
2889
Terry G
2809
Herbie Gaines
2799
Bill Osofsky
2782
Harriet Ames
2773
Roy Cooper
2751
Lisa Gundling
2698
MFB III
2654
Dan Windowman
2573
Nigel Quin
2558
Tom Tracy
2524
Jerry Jakala
2518
Michael LeBlanc
2505
nightengale
2499
Polly Hager
2496
Al Alvarez
2493
David Fontaine
2461
Gary Gray X
2448
Eric Thome
2401
Hummingbird
2290
Sharon I. Wells
2271
Ande Rasmussen
2263
Stan Loh
2228
Judy Hollier
2215
beechnut79
2202
Erica Ellis
2191
Sam Wilson
2177
Shayne Vaughan
2125
Idamarie Naelitz
2121
Dan Sullivan
2116
Mary Lou Sudkamp
2096
TrumanCoyote
2038
TamsNumber4
2023
Annie Tennisco
2008
Marty Helly
1997
Ria (Elizabeth)
1991
Richard Scott
1984
DukeWill
1963
Charlann Shepherd
1946
Travis david
1929
Ray Thyer
1910
Dan O'Connell
1909
Wendy D
1904
Clint Anglin
1867
Heidi Thompson
1851
Clairejeanne
1850
David Wright
1824
Cindy LaRosa
1822
Larry Williams
1723
Neil Cotton
1706
Steven August Rieck
1675
Ronald Boyt
1606
PopTodd
1605
Ashleigh Wehmeyer
1589
Linda Anthony
1549
Cal
1548
Noel Downs
1545
Jack Swain
1537
Pete Larsen
1532
R. Shayne Vaughan
1529
Ann Tygart
1512
Janice Messer
1497
Gregory Watton
1483
Kay-lynn Carew
1478
Kurt Fortmeyer
1477
Kevin Edward Rose
1449
Tom Breshers
1440
Ralph Blight
1438
Sofa King Bixby
1432
Chuck Crowe
1429
Kenneth Cade
1416
cindyrella
1406
Letha Allen
1402
Stan Simons
1384
mattbanx
1356
Rick Heenan
1346
Rick Norton
1341
Charlie Wong
1332
Randall Baker
1327
James B. Mitchell
1325
Tom Franz
1317
KevinP
1304
in2piano
1278
bholt
1265
DakLander
1243
Jeff Van Devender
1237
scottandrew
1236
RogerS
1217
Christine Ledford
1215
Lynman Bacolor
1208
Glen King
1201
joewatt
1194
IdeaGuy
1174
Gary E. Andrews
1141
Jen Shaner
1139
Michelle Chapman
1131
Jan Petter
1124
Kathy Bampfield
1120
Diane Ewing
1112
Vicarn
1079
MidniteBob
1075
BobbyJoe
1059
Vondelle
1049
Iggy
1040
Bree Griffith
1038
S.DEE
1016
Gerry
1016
Tony A
1014
Jeannette Desnoyers
989
yann
987
Tony Whitehead
986
argo
983
peaden
981
Doug/Liszt Laughing
969
Trudi Southerland
967
joro
960
Wolvman
953
PeteG
950
Clark Dickinson
950
My Stunt Brain
945
Jen Warner
931
Ian Ferrin
927
John Inglett
927
Patrick Bryant
909
Jak Kelly
906
Nelson
905
Steve West
890
krtinberg
883
Petra
874
Michael Thomas Ellis
863
Barkin' Barney
861
summeoyo
853
Curtis Cameron
845
RJC
842
unwanted_guitarist
840
Brenda152
836
Drifter
823
Jean Larson
822
johannasvision
815
Nadia
813
Susan Lainey
797
Juan
780
frahmes
779
Ms.Goody Haines
776
Christine Mascott
774
Ozone Pete
772
Steve Dockendorf
762
teletwang
762
Shirley E Matthews
760
Andrew Aversa
756
Accelerator
751
airun
737
kaboombahchuck
737
Dave Gill
735
tbryson
704
3daveyO3
701
Dixie
695
Joy Boy
694
Jim Offerman
692
CowboySlim
691
Ott Lukk
689
ant
688
Terry Moore
687
Doug Buche
686
Knute
679
Steve Vaclavik
678
Lee Arten
672
Mark Schuessler
669
Sausagelink
660
Andy K
652
Katziis
637
quality
631
thunder_road_2051
622
CG King
621
douglas
618
Diana Tyler
614
Mel
612
Richard Maclemale
607
R.T.MOORE
606
BobDobbins
601
NaomiSue
598
Doc Lovett
592
Roy M. Schnug
590
heatherdcowles
589
Shandy
587
Ria
583
TAMERA64
580
Paul H. Gaines
570
qbaum
567
leanne47960
561
JanValJohansen
559
Michael Meal
558
Michael Hollomon
556
Mikal Hartley
555
cozmicslop
553
Tink2
549
Marlene Palmer
545
nitepiano
541
Sharpe Lurker
540
Tom W.
539
TheCiscoKid
539
musica
537
Wes Tibbets
530
Sharon Irene Wells
529
Tim in Va
528
deanbell
528
Todd Strachan
528
Andy Kemp
527
RobertK
522
Roderic
514
Puddleglum
512
King Song o' Man
511
BB Wilbur
510
pRISCILLA
510
Jody K Smith
509
Perfectpitch
509
Duncan Wells
501
TerriLynnBlues
499
goodfolks
497
Doug Heard
495
Dan Tindall
489
Melissa Evans
483
Stu
481
Steve P.
479
Terrill Coggins
469
Van Borden
465
Robert D. Gann
462
KathyW
461
Moosesong
459
allenb
450
les_paul_gurl
448
trush48
448
fanito
446
Mark Cockerill
444
Aaron Johnson
442
dmk
442
Zeek
437
EaglesDreams2
436
DGR
433
Janet Snow
433
Meg Engell
432
Stephen D
431
Emmy
430
Jim Colyer
427
Doug Barnett
427
Tobias B White
426
Mike Parrish
424
Rick Maines
424
Rob L
423
arealrush
422
marquez
422
Steve Cooke
419
kit
417
Softkrome
413
nikkigal201
411
Randy P. Gendron
410
Russ Clayton
408
RRon
408
kyrksongs
407
Debra
407
VNORTH
406
eb
405
Cognac
404
Laura G.
403
Uncle Steve
403
StrCountry1
401
Pamela Bowne
401
Midnite Bob
400
9ne
399
cuebald
395
Hobart
394
bluelitenin
394
Mary Gardner
393
Davyboy49
392
Anne Meredith-Will
392
Barry Crannell
391
GT Acoustic
389
Smile
388
EdPerrone
387
GJShades
387
Brenda Lowry
387
Steve Humes
384
Ezt
382
beancounter
381
A Gun Called Maria
381
brandon kilgore
380
Marla
380
tone
378
Bob_Leslie
377
Stevens119
374
java
374
nightingale
374
Teddie Cochran Music
372
nitetrapper
371
spidey
371
coalminer
370
sweetsong
367
danny
366
Tracy Harris
362
Thetuneman
360
Jim Ryan
355
Irwin
351
Bluesriff
350
Z - man
350
Mike Siegel
350
Nathan Baker
348
John K
345
Nick Holbrook
344
Mary Lemanski
344
Jaden
341
richard murrey
341
JamesDF5
340
Ronald Boyte
340
SimpleSimon
340
TheBaz
339
leif
339
Steggy
339
lane1777
338
Kennan Zishka
336
Canadianryme
336
tonedeaf
336
Andy Dinnell
333
rickwork
332
Eddie Ray
332
Cher Klosner
332
papaG
329
Wayne Brown
328
Bob Lever
328
Johnboy
327
Helicon1
326
lucian
325
Richard Stringfellow
325
Ricky Layne
323
Kevin Miller
322
Charles Kirkland
321
Muskie
319
kc
319
TxBrownEyedBlond
318
Doug Spears
315
brokenwing
314
Z. Mulls
313
Teri Foreman-Black
313
ptondreau
313
April Johns
312
ONOFFON
311
Songwriterdemos
309
Philjo
308
Dennis H. Harbour
308
Jeff Epstein
306
CanisLupus
305
FrankWilliamson
305
Ann Feld
305
Dannyk1
304
guildslinger
304
trush
304
Latteta Theresa
301
Anna Marie
301
billrocker
301
Eric Baker
299
Pete Evanson
299
Bill Assumpcao
298
Mike Worrall
298
johnfindlay
297
ed323
297
Twisted Texan
295
abraham is burning
293
Ellen M
292
pafaustine
291
lizzorn
290
nicnac49
290
ddreuter
289
Stefan des Lauriers
288
Heather N. Orwig
286
Char
285
ktunes
283
pomeranj
280
mastrose
279
pammie
279
FixX
278
Andy-S-1407
278
Jan Johansen
277
pd
277
Dayson
277
Kaika Kale
276
Lady Fitzgerald
274
Duane O'Mac
273
Kris Karr
273
John Scott
272
Mike Claxton
272
studiojazzrockguitarX
272
December Rock Star
271
David Hooper
270
OH Napier
268
Ken
268
PrayDaily
268
FastEddie
268
Steve Altonian
266
AJ Baker
265
gkwaters
263
Natalie Brown
262
MrsStash
257
frimpy
253
Katie Powner
252
amccarthy
251
jeff
251
BitWhys
249
John Marnie
248
Pramod Ninan
247
Scoot1
247
Stag
244
Aaron
243
MHFair
243
ChrisYoung
243
Rocgae
243
ric4music
243
Ken Randall
242
cody sloan
242
Keye Kirkland
242
AutumnEyes
242
Bass2x
242
Lyndyn
242
Michael Downing
240
Redlady8029
239
kmaquilan2000
239
maccharles
238
ShimmerPuppy
238
Paul Churchfield
236
songman
236
James B.Williamson
236
Bernd Harmsen
235
Marian Longfield
235
Tom Solanto
234
AKA Wordsmith
233
Kenna
233
MaxG
232
FreewheelNat
229
CalmDog
229
Dak Lander
228
Maye
228
TDBrown
228
avweek
227
David Guy
227
Alek
225
Sk8boi
225
Jim Pirinelli
225
Vicki Shields
224
SongMom
224
songbird1
223
Ken Damkier
222
SimonRead
222
AntonyW
222
jt wojahn
222
Kitty84
221
sparty5
220
johnnie7au
219
Terry Fernihough
218
cody sloan Jr
218
Nicholaus Billings
218
Droptine
217
Gilead
217
CountrySongwriter
217
dtrain1234
216
thinkhaus
216
snail1
216
Delphia Blize
215
writie
215
paul schmid
215
tim houlihan
214
Optikal Illusion
214
loonylyricslady
214
markus-ky
214
Scott Philip Stewart
213
Folkie
212
PenniJPF
211
Michael Wind
209
bob2
208
Slimphaat
208
JTHOMP
208
Jackie444
207
Pianosam
207
tom scudiero
206
Stephen John (singch
206
Bobby Wayne
205
John Webb
204
randy
204
Diane Jessurun
204
Byron "Garknuckle"
204
PeterJ
204
ColmT
203
billdraper
202
darby
202
Kathy97
202
Kap
201
jdruss1
201
jeffok
201
Chris Maurer
201
Darius Babylon
199
EasyHero
199
bigm1978
199
Martin James
198
reggie miles
197
Songdog
196
breezy
195
pkatjjames
195
EmmitSycamore
195
sharla
194
Boaz
194
westofnashville
194
Rob T
193
ErisaRei
191
Harry J
191
Nevergoback
190
Raven
190
John Cook
189
MichSongs
188
Papos
187
Roxy Cain
186
Mick Choder
186
JMarie
186
nickdrake2001
186
Briggitta
186
Corinne
185
bm5555
185
Frank N Furter
185
matanglawin
184
BeverlyRead
184
Renikay
184
Perry Smith
183
Michele
183
Ethan
180
eyesound
178
emmalemma
177
LadyLyricist
177
Split Level
176
Alan
176
Patti Smith
175
Dennis Harbour
174
SexyRexy
174
Guitar1221
174
Nubzilla
174
RE_Goldenbird
172
splitpeasongs
171
Gerry Manning
171
anne
170
Peter Kristian
170
James M
169
Kester
169
bernie lamb
169
Barry Williams
168
Dave Derbes
167
Chris Dasch
167
vontanner
165
Karla
165
mattsurowiec
165
Alador
164
Direct Current
164
AmberBrooke
164
Jerry Stidman
164
RLD
164
rodhughey
164
theairshack
164
BonnieHickling
163
JoDell
162
cool_E
162
babyblue
162
EdThomas
161
Pop Superhero
161
flatlandsmedia
161
Ernest Whaley
160
jjlanuza
160
Country Coyote
159
Cpt.Analog
159
RecklessRodeo
159
Carlos Tabora
159
adf
158
Phil Chapman
158
Bater
157
skido85
157
Stephen Brooke
157
Lisa Butler
157
Dude McLean
156
terrorist hunter
156
JakeWhalen
156
jmsocia
156
DannyM
155
Gary Gustin
155
Howlin' Hobbit
154
Billy Darnell
153
Tom Zart
152
Bruce Goldish
152
Tom Stephens
151
songmachine
150
VDickinson
150
Aaron Corley
149
thomasongs
149
Raymond de Leur Jr
148
rjdinino
148
joshrp
148
Sparkplug Johnny
147
RonTocknell
147
Tim Perry
147
Darrell Lee
146
Brina
146
JamieMarie
146
enuf2Bonyrwayne
146
guscave
146
Marvin Adcock
146
Jennifer Schmitt
145
Flammable
145
LindaK
145
Paul Radelat
145
Nathan K
144
wienerdog
144
John Parker
142
Wayne Hamilton
142
prizmlights
141
Beth Austin
141
steve3927
140
lilgirlfaith
140
Dan Monk
140
jive4005
140
fremontjohn
140
Borderlord
139
Sammy
139
nanette
139
Gazoo101077
138
HENNIE LINTVELT
138
welee_woowoo
137
jeff2
137
HauserJustin
136
davidallentv
135
Sandy Andina
135
Tony Gunter
135
Marc Novoselec
135
rivetingriffs
134
GMG
134
ejlawrence
134
Dorsey Baker
133
Jeza
133
chpastor
133
John Crandall
132
dee
132
Chrissy
132
Mike Hansen
132
Vince
132
eharris
132
Wayne Longtin
132
Jim McGonigle
132
sabrinao
132
marvin k. perkins
131
chapman
131
Mtezzybear
131
Balentine Productions
131
Ray Withrow
131
Songpusher1
130
Just Plain Steve
130
c.c.cherrier
129
RLBerry
129
Nick Edelstein
128
Stacy
128
saitie
128
MATT STONEHAM
127
ShowTunesmith
127
merlinxwiz
126
rce_otr
126
kaleo4
126
ridenrose
125
Kenny Holcomb
125
player4
125
spiritual
125
BEN
124
Lee Smith
124
Conner
124
PCStudios
124
Jonathan DeBoe
124
Wyndham
123
Ward
123
jmartino
123
mach1mike
123
Roy Harris
123
Brian Dorn
123
robert wynn
122
neoism
121
KC_2002
121
mikeredwine
121
Diane Coffman
120
farmboy
120
relay
120
Monica L. Yasher
119
priceless
119
Miles Maxwell
119
TheDanMan
119
jennifer mangum
119
tna0708
119
Steve Robinson
119
janice green
119
SteveHVasil
118
Melody
118
Songbob
118
Christopher Allen
118
gpsongwriter
118
Cecilia
118
Robert Dean
117
CLAY
117
Pam Bowen
116
Sonny B. Bell
116
DawGe
116
Jules
116
buzzard
116
Anna/Without the Blonde
116
cliff turner
116
Jayro
116
R1NGG1T
115
k wayland
115
the_lyricwriter
115
LadyLyricist1
115
Maureen Fichten
115
biskitboy
114
Linda Whitney
114
mani
114
chazma2
114
donmartin
114
Kevin Rivers
114
intuitionartist
Page 1 of 2 12>
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#745745 - 08/17/09 08:31 AM President Obama might get Health Care right!
Mike Dunbar
JPF Mentor


Registered: 04/13/01
Posts: 8203
Loc: Nashville Tennessee
http://www.theadvertiser.com/article/20090817/NEWS01/90817003/-1/rss01

President Obama is giving signs that he might go along with a bill that abandons government run health insurance.

This solution would open up not-for-profit health insurance plans, owned and run by the private sector. These private insurance companies would compete with the for-profit plans, naturally causing some to lower prices and to drive others to offer high quality plans for premium prices.

The government would spend a few billion (hey, what's a few billion?) in "start up" money, and of course they would attach strings to that start up money, but they wouldn't be running the show, only providing mandates. That's the concession we libertarians would be making for this. You have to let the Democrats spend too much money on some things or they wouldn't be Democrats.

To me this is almost perfect, because it will get both the radical Liberals and the radical Conservatives angry. Howard Dean already is against it, so right there, it can't be all bad \:\)

If this is the plan that gets adopted, it will be a masterful political stroke. President Obama, unless something extreme happens, will not have a viable Democratic challenger in the next presidential election. Without having to run a primary campaign, he doesn't have to pander to the far left.

For the nation, this would be a uniquely United States solution to health care. It would allow the private sector to run health care insurance as a not-for-profit, probably allowing charitable donations for those times when the market naturally undergoes downturns. There wouldn't be a new government run behemoth draining government resources and growing the federal monster. The good, decent people of the United States can and will, if allowed, take care of those who fall on hard times.

I applaud President Obama for considering this. If it passes without the tentacles of government getting too far into it, this may be a truly REVOLUTIONARY solution.
_________________________
Anybody who’s made it will tell you, you can make it. Anyone who hasn’t made it will tell you, you can’t -John Mayer

Success is simply a matter of luck. Ask any failure. -Earl Wilson

It's only music. -niteshift

Mike Dunbar Music


Top
#745748 - 08/17/09 08:54 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Mike Dunbar]
Kevin Emmrich
Top 20 Poster


Registered: 02/24/07
Posts: 8632
Loc: Crozet, VA
I read about this shift a couple of days ago and I said to myself "hmmmm", might be a good idea. No matter what happens, I am glad to see that Obama is not afraid to make major changes to his plans in order to get something done.

Kevin
_________________________
"Make Every Line Count"
Kevin at Soundclick and ... more Soundclick
skype: Kevin.Emmrich

Top
#745751 - 08/17/09 09:11 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Kevin Emmrich]
Ray E. Strode
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 05/22/01
Posts: 4540
Loc: Brunswick, Ga. USA
I would guess that since the people are speaking, loud and clear it is the only thing Obama can do.

It isn't the Federal Government's job to provide public care anyway. I want the Social Programs returned to the States where the money will stay in the State and the people in each state can decide what kind of program they want.

The costs may not be any less but it could be.
_________________________
Ray E. Strode

Top
#745785 - 08/17/09 11:07 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Ray E. Strode]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
One thing I have figured out in the last couple years is Obama is a very. very intelligent man. A perfect Politician. He rose from a simple community organizer to the President of the United States in a very short time and he did it without accomplishing much of anything.
He did it by telling the people exactly what they wanted to hear and making them believe he actually believed it too and he could actually make it happen.
He can flipflop better than anyone I have ever seen. And will be able to take credit for it if it works.

Think about it. He raised $700 MILLION for his Presidential run. That in itself is enormous.
For this I have to applaud him. I still don't like him.
If he has the ability to recognize the true wishes of the people and give them something that works he will leave a great legacy.
Whether the rest of his term will show as much promise is still in question. I still think he is a socialist and would like nothing better than to undo our Constitution but he may be tricky enough to pull it off and still make the people love him for it.
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#745808 - 08/17/09 12:15 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
Kevin Emmrich
Top 20 Poster


Registered: 02/24/07
Posts: 8632
Loc: Crozet, VA
I tend to agree with you Bill, but I do feel that he has a little bit of the "Bill Clinton" pragmatism about him -- and he's learning quicker than Bill did.

A health care reform bill that works and has at least some support from the republican side of the congress is better than a health care reform act that passes purely on a partisan vote.

Now if he could just do something about the deficit. Maybe he'll get lucky like Clinton did and preside over a market/economy boom which will help balance the budget. The huge debt that hangs over all of us will take a long time to fix.

Kevin
_________________________
"Make Every Line Count"
Kevin at Soundclick and ... more Soundclick
skype: Kevin.Emmrich

Top
#745812 - 08/17/09 12:26 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Kevin Emmrich]
Mike Dunbar
JPF Mentor


Registered: 04/13/01
Posts: 8203
Loc: Nashville Tennessee
I think he might even be a better politician. He's getting the far left mad, that will keep them vocal. It's possible that they will push the Dems in Congress to move a left of center agenda which could bring on a Republican backlash similar to the Clinton days. Obama wielding the veto with a Republican Congress could indeed bring about a few years of a market boom. As much as the market likes Republicans, it really likes Republicans with checks and balances. That's what brought on the Clinton boom.
_________________________
Anybody who’s made it will tell you, you can make it. Anyone who hasn’t made it will tell you, you can’t -John Mayer

Success is simply a matter of luck. Ask any failure. -Earl Wilson

It's only music. -niteshift

Mike Dunbar Music


Top
#745825 - 08/17/09 01:40 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Mike Dunbar]
Gary Gray X



Registered: 12/16/07
Posts: 2461
Loc: TEXAS
I totally agree with Bill, I don't like any president that would try to ruin our country intentionally or not on either party
Top
#745826 - 08/17/09 01:41 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Mike Dunbar]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
Yup, It would be nice to see a balanced budget.
I just hope he can do it without touching defense or intelligence.

I was gonna say Military Intelligence but that would be one of the Oxymoronic thingy's
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#745828 - 08/17/09 01:45 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
Quote:
I tend to agree with you Bill, but I do feel that he has a little bit of the "Bill Clinton" pragmatism about him -- and he's learning quicker than Bill did.


Absolutely Kevin.
Mike D and I were talking about this yesterday at Joanne's Recording session. (At Rick Ott's studio if anybody needs a great place to record).
Clinton was a very smart guy. Still is.
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#745831 - 08/17/09 02:24 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
Cacti Jake
Casual Observer


Registered: 05/22/09
Posts: 34
BHO is pushing a freedom stealing plan - This abortion should go up in smoke / Those who would sacrifice freedom for security deserve neither!
Top
#745846 - 08/17/09 03:56 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Cacti Jake]
John W. Selleck
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 04/07/07
Posts: 3463
Loc: NJ
It is very smart to throw up a white flag when you are being beaten badly. If that is what is happenning and it isn't another effort to back door the same idea. As far as making the extreme left mad? I think he is part of the extreme left. The right, all of them, not just the extreme have been upset for a long time by his stated goals. A balanced budget? With all the money already spent, and all he is planning on spending, I don't see a balanced budget for at least 20 years. It will take us that long to get out of this hole. Of course he could always take all the money from defense to help out...
I do hope this new program works but I think it is just another spend/spend/spend social program.
_________________________
Have a goodun,

John W. Selleck BMI Songwriter
A day without learning is a day lost

http://www.soundclick.com/johnsings
http://www.soundclick.com/johnwselleck
http://www.soundclick.com/johnselleck

Top
#751131 - 09/10/09 07:42 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: John W. Selleck]
Duncan Wells
Serious Contributor


Registered: 08/08/09
Posts: 509
During Obama's speech I was waiting to hear something about young families and the cost of having a child. In Canada it's covered. We have two children - both adults now. They almost put us in the poorhouse raising the buggers but it didn't cost anything to bring them into the world. Does anyone know if, under Obama's HCR plan, will child birth be covered? JMO but I thought his speech was very clever. Except for the tiny outburst by crazy Joe Wilson, things went quite wll. A few times throughout the presentation it almost seemed that both parties were on the same side. That was nice to see for a change.
Top
#751152 - 09/10/09 08:36 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Duncan Wells]
ben willis
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 04/10/06
Posts: 4842
Loc: Ft. Myers, FL. USA
Originally Posted By: Duncan Wells
Except for the tiny outburst by crazy Joe Wilson,


Why would you call him crazy?

Top
#751156 - 09/10/09 08:49 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Duncan Wells]
Doug Heard
Serious Contributor


Registered: 03/17/05
Posts: 497
Loc: On the Road USA
Originally Posted By: Duncan Wells
During Obama's speech I was waiting to hear something about young families and the cost of having a child. In Canada it's covered. We have two children - both adults now. They almost put us in the poorhouse raising the buggers but it didn't cost anything to bring them into the world. Does anyone know if, under Obama's HCR plan, will child birth be covered? JMO but I thought his speech was very clever. Except for the tiny outburst by crazy Joe Wilson, things went quite wll. A few times throughout the presentation it almost seemed that both parties were on the same side. That was nice to see for a change.


Why would the cost of child birth be a government responsibility.

Top
#751161 - 09/10/09 09:18 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Doug Heard]
Duncan Wells
Serious Contributor


Registered: 08/08/09
Posts: 509
Ben, um...how about stupid instead of crazy? I don't care what your politics are man. You just don't do that. Sorry but, again, JMO, but it was a pretty tacky, small-minded thing to do. I think any other president would have pointed a finger and had Joe removed. Let's just call it "unprofessional behaviour" and move along, shall we? And Doug, I never said I thought it was the "government's responsibility" to cover the cost of child care. I asked a question. The question was: "Does anyone know if, under Obama's HCR plan, will child birth be covered?" If you don't know the answer to the question fine, but please don't do a drive-by on me, ok? Thanks!


Does anyone know the answer to the question?

Top
#751212 - 09/11/09 12:07 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Duncan Wells]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
Duncan
As far as I can tell Child birth would be covered. It certainly isn't excluded.
Of course if you are an illegal alien in this country it is already covered. \:\)

Congressman Wilson's comment may have been bad form but we do have a constitutional right to free speech in this country. It does not stop at the President's door or the steps of Congress.

Actually I was saying "that's a lie" at the television as I listened. Of course I was sitting in my own living room and we are, after all, Kings of our own castles. Are we not?


Edited by Bill Robinson (09/11/09 12:14 AM)
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#751222 - 09/11/09 01:46 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
Bob Cushing
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 07/20/05
Posts: 4109
Loc: cincinnati oh usa
Originally Posted By: Bill Robinson
Quote:
I tend to agree with you Bill, but I do feel that he has a little bit of the "Bill Clinton" pragmatism about him -- and he's learning quicker than Bill did.


Absolutely Kevin.
Mike D and I were talking about this yesterday at Joanne's Recording session. (At Rick Ott's studio if anybody needs a great place to record).
Clinton was a very smart guy. Still is.
Yup, too bad he couldn't keep "little Bill" in check, otherwise history would have been pretty kind to him.
_________________________
bc

Top
#751243 - 09/11/09 05:57 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bob Cushing]
John W. Selleck
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 04/07/07
Posts: 3463
Loc: NJ
What's really funny is that a lot of the same people who are crucifying this congressman are the same ones who were applauding people like the dixie chicks when they were saying things a lot worse.
_________________________
Have a goodun,

John W. Selleck BMI Songwriter
A day without learning is a day lost

http://www.soundclick.com/johnsings
http://www.soundclick.com/johnwselleck
http://www.soundclick.com/johnselleck

Top
#751264 - 09/11/09 08:26 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: John W. Selleck]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
John I think the outrage here is over the timing of the act. It is considered rude and against decorum to say anything bad when the President is Speaking to Congress.

Of course you can applaud him and agree with him all you want even if he is lying through his teeth. That is OK.
But outbursts of dissension are unacceptable.
Pretty hypocritical, huh?
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#751265 - 09/11/09 08:29 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
NaomiSue
Serious Contributor


Registered: 06/17/09
Posts: 601
I'll believe it when I see it, for now I'll chock it up to him entertaining us conservatives so we'll shut up for a few.
_________________________
I do custom myspace pages! Check out my work http://www.myspace.com/naomisuemontgomery and http://www.myspace.com/nashvilleapril email me at nmontgomery1984@yahoo.com for mor info or message me on JPF!

Top
#751271 - 09/11/09 08:51 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: NaomiSue]
John W. Selleck
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 04/07/07
Posts: 3463
Loc: NJ
I didn't say what he did was appropriate. What I really said was we have two different standards here. One for judging conservatives and one for judging liberals. How many left leaning media types said anything about the chicks statements made in front of a foriegn audience that doesn't like Americans to begin with? Personally I don't agree with the timing of either act. I would just like to see both sides treated the same.
_________________________
Have a goodun,

John W. Selleck BMI Songwriter
A day without learning is a day lost

http://www.soundclick.com/johnsings
http://www.soundclick.com/johnwselleck
http://www.soundclick.com/johnselleck

Top
#751331 - 09/11/09 01:19 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: John W. Selleck]
Scott Campbell
Top 10 Poster


Registered: 07/22/05
Posts: 10861
Loc: Lakeland, FL, USA
Originally Posted By: John W. Selleck
I didn't say what he did was appropriate. What I really said was we have two different standards here. One for judging conservatives and one for judging liberals. How many left leaning media types said anything about the chicks statements made in front of a foriegn audience that doesn't like Americans to begin with? Personally I don't agree with the timing of either act. I would just like to see both sides treated the same.


John, I think it's in how we perceive things.

I know that some conservative folks here think that liberals are much more insulting to conservatives than vice-versa.

Yet I know liberals who think they are inclusive but that the conservatives are mean spirited.

They are as convinced in their hearts that this is true every bit as much as the folks here who think the opposite. In fact, they are starting to become annoyed with the President for reaching out to conservatives instead of steam-rolling over them (which I think would be a mistake).

And if you start hurling examples of insults to conservatives they will hurl back counter examples.

And neither side will run out of examples.

I think it's human nature to remember criticism of ourselves as attacks and think of our attacks on others as honest fact-telling.

So if any of you are thinking, "that's just not true - conservatives are willing to work with liberals but the liberals keep slamming us and telling untruths about us", you should remember that there is someone out there who is working to support a family, considers himself patriotic, and feels exactly the opposite.

That is why I believe respect for office is important - it helps to keep discouse at a civil level. Lose that, and nothing will get done.

Just my opinion, of course \:\)

Scott

Top
#751348 - 09/11/09 03:21 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Scott Campbell]
Doug Heard
Serious Contributor


Registered: 03/17/05
Posts: 497
Loc: On the Road USA
Quote:
That is why I believe respect for office is important - it helps to keep discouse at a civil level. Lose that, and nothing will get done.


When you are talking about government "nothing will get done" is a good thing.

Top
#751349 - 09/11/09 03:26 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
Duncan Wells
Serious Contributor


Registered: 08/08/09
Posts: 509
Would be covered? Ok...thanks for that. Your comment on illegal aliens already being covered for childbirth, are you kidding" You put the little smiley thing at the end of it so I'm guessing you are.

On Joe Wilson's "outburst", I do understand the right to free speech and I support the right to free speech along with artistic expression, but when a "liar" like Joe Wilson (free speech remember?) calls someone a liar when he either knows full well that it is not a lie OR is not intelligent or competent enough to read and understand page 132 sec 242 of the bill then there is a problem. Anyone can call anyone a liar but Joe, to my knowledge, hasn't yet offered any explanation as to why he called Obama a liar. If he blurted it out because he has the "right" to blurt it out, ok, good for him for exercising his right but without supporting his claim all he did was draw attention to himself.

And finally, GASP!!! You as well called Obama a liar on the issue of illegal immigrants being covered? What do you base your accusation on? What part of the bill did you read that causes you to call him a liar when it comes to illegal immigrants being included in the HCR package? What "words" in the bill causes you to believe Obama was lying? Just wondering. Thanks!

Top
#751364 - 09/11/09 04:32 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Duncan Wells]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
Duncan
There is NOTHING in the bill that says Illegal aliens will not get free health care. NOTHING. Show me one place in HR 3200 that says Illegal Immigrants will not get free health care.
If there is I implore you or someone else to show it to me. I'd love to be proved wrong.

They get it now and they will get it after the bill is passed. So no I am not kidding.

There have been several attempts to get a provision placed in the bill that would require proof of Citizenship or an ID card or anything that would prevent any Illegal Alien from walking into any emergency room in this country and be treated. It simply is not there.
Illegal immigrants can and do walk into emergency rooms here and have their babies. FREE, Nada, no cost, my tax dollars and my High insurance premiums pay for it and NOTHING in this bill will change that.

Page 132 Sec 242?
Well sir I have read it. I am not a lawyer and I think it is pretty clear. So is the section that describes what it means.
You are pointing out the "Affordable Credit Eligible Individual" provision.
Read it again sir. AS I understand it all that does is define who will be eligible for health insurance exchange and other items in the bill. Illegal immigrants don't need health insurance. They already get FREE health care here. The lawyers filled this bill with all kinds of misdirection.
Search the bill for that term, Affordable Credit Eligible Individual, see what comes up. What it means and what it refers to. There is also no provision for a person to prove they are a legal immigrant.
The only place in this bill that even mentions citizenship is section 1415 dealing with whistle blowers.

Why is it so hard for people to understand that. Illegal Immigrants DO NOT PAY FOR HEALTH CARE NOW AND THEY WON"T PAY FOR IT UNDER HR3200.
It is illegal for any emergency room in this country to refuse treatment to anyone. They are not allowed to ask for proof of citizenship. They have to treat you even if you tell them you have no money and cannot pay for the treatment. HR 3200 does not negate that. If you need hospitalization for treatment it cannot be denied.

I won't even go into the other untruth's in that speech.

BTW
On what do you base calling Joe Wilson a liar?


Edited by Bill Robinson (09/11/09 04:52 PM)
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#751369 - 09/11/09 04:46 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
Gary Gray X



Registered: 12/16/07
Posts: 2461
Loc: TEXAS
my best friend's wife is the head nurse in a major Dallas hospital and what Bill says is true and has been true for ages, some of us see the light while some can't and no matter what we are all in the same mess
Top
#751374 - 09/11/09 05:00 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Gary Gray X]
Kevin Emmrich
Top 20 Poster


Registered: 02/24/07
Posts: 8632
Loc: Crozet, VA
Quote:
It is illegal for any emergency room in this country to refuse treatment to anyone.

Bill,

I don't think that will ever change. So what we have is not a health care problem, per se, but an immigration problem. So if we, somehow, solve the illegal immigration issue, then that part of the health care equation will be taken care of.

I don't think it is reasonable to expect a health care bill to solve the immigration disaster.

Kevin
_________________________
"Make Every Line Count"
Kevin at Soundclick and ... more Soundclick
skype: Kevin.Emmrich

Top
#751375 - 09/11/09 05:11 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Kevin Emmrich]
ben willis
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 04/10/06
Posts: 4842
Loc: Ft. Myers, FL. USA
Kevin's right. It's a rock and hard place issue. It's human nature to help someone in trouble. No matter what is in the bill, we can't turn people away in an emergency. That doesn't include going to the emergency room for sniffles or doctor visits. We can't ask emergency room visitors for their "papers" while they have a bullet in their head.

Congress needs to do a lot more work on this. What's the hurry?

Top
#751380 - 09/11/09 05:36 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: ben willis]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
Immigration is not the issue here.
Whether or not this Health care bill will allow Illegal immigrants access to health care is the issue.
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#751383 - 09/11/09 05:42 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
ben willis
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 04/10/06
Posts: 4842
Loc: Ft. Myers, FL. USA
Bill, there is health care which I agree with you on 100%, and there are trauma cases which need immediate attention. That's the rock and hard place that needs to be explained.
Top
#751384 - 09/11/09 05:49 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: ben willis]
Kevin Emmrich
Top 20 Poster


Registered: 02/24/07
Posts: 8632
Loc: Crozet, VA
Originally Posted By: Bill
Immigration is not the issue here.
Whether or not this Health care bill will allow Illegal immigrants access to health care is the issue.


LOL! After reading Ben's good post, I said to myself "Wow!, we might be coming to reasonable consensus of opinion here". I guess we got to send it back to committee!

Kevin
_________________________
"Make Every Line Count"
Kevin at Soundclick and ... more Soundclick
skype: Kevin.Emmrich

Top
#751389 - 09/11/09 06:09 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Kevin Emmrich]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
Ben
I guess it might mean you have an ID card in your pocket that says you are an American Citizen and qualify as an "Affordable Credit Eligible Individual". Or you are in the database that Obama is going to require all the hospitals to be connected to.

No one is suggesting that life threatening conditions won't be treated. That is not what we are talking about here.

Of course they could also allow them treatment but they would then be arrested as illegals and deported. But that would require asking them for proof they are a citizen and you know that ain't gonna happen.
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#751394 - 09/11/09 06:31 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
ben willis
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 04/10/06
Posts: 4842
Loc: Ft. Myers, FL. USA
Bill, I'm not for this health care debacle at all. We need tort reform and competition of insurance companies across state lines. That's it.

It just appeared that you didn't care about emergency responses to anyone who needs it, which would be a lot of illegals. No matter how they dress it up, we can't turn down emergency cases.

Emergency room visits should not be routine doctor visits. They should be trauma centers. So we agree.

Top
#751529 - 09/12/09 11:00 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: ben willis]
Mike Dunbar
JPF Mentor


Registered: 04/13/01
Posts: 8203
Loc: Nashville Tennessee
I don't want people being asked for their "papers." Sorry. Years ago, I was walking down the street at 4am, coming home from a gig and I got pulled over by the police. The officer asked for my identification. I had none on me. I had walked two miles to the gig so didn't even bring my wallet. The officer told me I needed to have identification. I told him, no, I didn't. If we don't have government controlled health care, then we won't need government "papers" to get health care.

I think there is a solution to the illegal immigration problem. It is simply a matter of stopping the illegal employers. If the states, for example, put in a $10,000 fine per case for hiring an illegal employee, then the illegal workers would move to another state. If all the states did it, they would move back to their home countries (Ireland, for example, has a surprisingly high amount of illegal workers here in the U.S.).

For the "anchor" babies? Simple. Yes, the baby is a citizen of the U.S. but the parent is not. The baby can stay, the parent must go. If the parent does not want to leave the baby, then the parent should take the baby back to their home country and let the child move to the U.S. when he or she is old enough. That child would then be a legal citizen with rights to work. That would slow down the anchor babies. I can hear the screams now. "You would do that to a BABY?" No, I wouldn't be doing that to a baby...the PARENT would be. And if the parent ever returned, they would be arrested for abandonment, which is already illegal.

Federal laws should protect citizens, not care for people.

Just wait. Once health care is socialized, wait and see how they want to make food a right. After all, who can be healthy without eating? And clothes. And shelter (wait, they're already doing tht, arent' they). And transportation. And music (oh, yeah, that's right, music is already free).

What a bunch of babies. \:\)



_________________________
Anybody who’s made it will tell you, you can make it. Anyone who hasn’t made it will tell you, you can’t -John Mayer

Success is simply a matter of luck. Ask any failure. -Earl Wilson

It's only music. -niteshift

Mike Dunbar Music


Top
#751539 - 09/12/09 11:24 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: ben willis]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
Ben
The Immigrant issue is really only a small part of the problem. But here is an example of how these things get so screwed up when you talk about how many people are using the system.

In California they released a report denying illegal immigrants used the emergency rooms more than insured persons, that Medi-cal patients actually used the Emergency rooms more than illegal immigrants.
There are about 6.6 Million people on the Medi-cal roles.
Here's the catch. California does not require proof of citizenship to have Medi-cal. It is estimated that at least 12 percent, and some estimates are much higher, of the recipients on Medi-cal are illegal immigrants. That's about 720,000 illegal immigrants on medi-cal. The majority of them use Emergency rooms as a clinic or go to local clinics.

So if you add those to the Illegals they report the numbers change. This is the kind of thing conservatives are concerned about.
No one is advocating letting seriously ill or injured people die in the streets. All I want is a system that is policed and prevents abuses of our health care system.
The only problem with that is more big government.

No matter how you look at it 12 Million people (by some estimates that is low)is a lot of people.

Now I need to quit worrying about this and go work on my new recording room.


Edited by Bill Robinson (09/12/09 11:26 AM)
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#751540 - 09/12/09 11:30 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
Quote:
For the "anchor" babies? Simple. Yes, the baby is a citizen of the U.S. but the parent is not.


Actually Mike I really don't believe that. I read the Constitution and the law and I am not so sure. but as you say IANAL.
I wonder if it has been challenged in the supreme court.
I'm sure it has.

But that's another issue.
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#751543 - 09/12/09 11:58 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
Mike Dunbar
JPF Mentor


Registered: 04/13/01
Posts: 8203
Loc: Nashville Tennessee
Bill, IANAL either, but I think you are confusing "natural born citizen" which some folks are using to de-legitimatize the Obama presidency, with "citizen."

I believe a citizen has a lower threshold, for example a naturalized citizen, than a "natural born" citizen.

This might shed some light:
http://www.uscis.gov/portal/site/uscis/m...00045f3d6a1RCRD

It defines "citizenship" as being "Birth, either within the territory of the United States or to U.S. citizen parents, or
Naturalization, the process of obtaining U.S. citizenship."
_________________________
Anybody who’s made it will tell you, you can make it. Anyone who hasn’t made it will tell you, you can’t -John Mayer

Success is simply a matter of luck. Ask any failure. -Earl Wilson

It's only music. -niteshift

Mike Dunbar Music


Top
#751545 - 09/12/09 12:08 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Mike Dunbar]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
I did a little digging.
It seems the issue has been before the supreme court several times and has been challenge in Congress a few times as well.
It seems to also be a matter of interpretation. By the Courts and by congress.
It appears the guy that wrote the 14th amendment did not intend for babies born to illegals to be automatically given citizenship. He just goofed and didn't word it clearly enough. So now it is a matter of interpretation.
My interpretation is....NO.
Unfortunately they forgot to say illegal immigrant anywhere in the law or the amendment.
But the immigration law could easily have cleared it up and still could. all they have to do is rewrite it..

This is the wikipedia article and I know you have to verify anything on wiki but I read this same thing other places.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourteenth_...izenship_Clause
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#751546 - 09/12/09 12:09 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Mike Dunbar]
Doug Heard
Serious Contributor


Registered: 03/17/05
Posts: 497
Loc: On the Road USA
Quote:
For the "anchor" babies? Simple. Yes, the baby is a citizen of the U.S. but the parent is not. The baby can stay, the parent must go. If the parent does not want to leave the baby, then the parent should take the baby back to their home country and let the child move to the U.S. when he or she is old enough. That child would then be a legal citizen with rights to work. That would slow down the anchor babies. I can hear the screams now. "You would do that to a BABY?" No, I wouldn't be doing that to a baby...the PARENT would be. And if the parent ever returned, they would be arrested for abandonment, which is already illegal.


I love it. That's the way it should be. The "anchor" babies have never been the problem it's the attendant come alongs that go with them. Separate the baby from the process. Sure the baby is a citizen, you ain't good by. I'm not sure if you could get them for abandonment to a program you set up, kind of like the new leave them at the firestation laws. But other wise the right approach.

I'd even have a lot of respect for the mother, deciding that being split from the baby would give the baby a better life and willing to break the law for it. Respect, but they still have to go back.

Top
#751547 - 09/12/09 12:14 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Doug Heard]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
Doug
It is not a given that these babies are citizens. Even the courts have argued over it. and have reversed themselves. Right now there is only an "assumption" that they are citizens.
There has never been a clear defined ruling on it from what I can find.
I think the law should be written to clearly define it once and for all. If they are going to let the baby be a citizen then they might as well grant it to the mother.

That the anchor babies have never been a problem is false. They and the mothers cost tax payers Millions in early health care and it is well known that the mothers come here and have their babies knowing full well they won't be sent home.
I know of a hospital in Michigan that closed their birthing unit because of it.

Quote:
In Parkland Memorial Hospital Dallas, the second busiest maternity ward in the United States, 70% of the women giving birth were illegal aliens. That added up to 11,200 babies for which Medicaid kicked in 34.5 million dollars to deliver these babies, the feds another 9.5 million and Dallas taxpayers tossed in 31.3 million. The average illegal patient is 25 years and giving birth to her second anchor baby.


http://www.fairus.org/site/PageServer?pagename=iic_immigrationissuecenters4608


Edited by Bill Robinson (09/12/09 12:22 PM)
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#751550 - 09/12/09 12:31 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
Mike Dunbar
JPF Mentor


Registered: 04/13/01
Posts: 8203
Loc: Nashville Tennessee
Well, there's law and there's law and there's the law of unintended consequences.

I believe in the Constitution and Bill of Rights. I believe it should be read in plain English and understood as such. It was not written for lawyers. Mostly, it was written to protect us from lawyers. The 14th amendment says:

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.

Now that sounds pretty clear to me. The problem is, in 1866, they didn't figure on the double edged sword of Democrats looking for votes and Republicans looking for cheap labor, combined with easier transportation and a corrupt neighbor country.

Yes, if laws such as HR 1868 get passed that would help tighten the loopholes, but I don't see any equivocation on the right of someone born here...even a test tube baby...being a citizen. (I know that would make Joe Wrabek, our most famous JPF test tube baby, very happy \:\) ).
_________________________
Anybody who’s made it will tell you, you can make it. Anyone who hasn’t made it will tell you, you can’t -John Mayer

Success is simply a matter of luck. Ask any failure. -Earl Wilson

It's only music. -niteshift

Mike Dunbar Music


Top
#751551 - 09/12/09 12:41 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Mike Dunbar]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
Mike
You are correct of course. You usually are but take another look
"subject to the jurisdiction thereof"
What does that mean?
Quote:
The phrase "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" was intended to exclude from automatic citizenship American-born persons whose allegiance to the United States was incomplete.


Accordingly the baby is claimed by the country it's mother is a citizen of, therefore it cannot claim citizenship here..
This has not been decided by the supreme court.
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#751554 - 09/12/09 01:22 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
Gary Gray X



Registered: 12/16/07
Posts: 2461
Loc: TEXAS
question: is there any other country in the world that gives automatic citizenship to the baby when it is born on foreign soil other than the mother's homeland? hope this question isn't too confusing
Top
#751557 - 09/12/09 01:41 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
NaomiSue
Serious Contributor


Registered: 06/17/09
Posts: 601
Originally Posted By: Bill Robinson

Unfortunately they forgot to say illegal immigrant anywhere in the law or the amendment.


That seems to be the case in a lot of situations. People just forget to mention things. I understand that back then they weren't worried as much about illegals. But still it's funny how some things never change. Forgetfulness runs rampant through our politics.
_________________________
I do custom myspace pages! Check out my work http://www.myspace.com/naomisuemontgomery and http://www.myspace.com/nashvilleapril email me at nmontgomery1984@yahoo.com for mor info or message me on JPF!

Top
#751558 - 09/12/09 01:44 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Gary Gray X]
NaomiSue
Serious Contributor


Registered: 06/17/09
Posts: 601
Originally Posted By: Gary D. Gray
question: is there any other country in the world that gives automatic citizenship to the baby when it is born on foreign soil other than the mother's homeland? hope this question isn't too confusing


LOL, no because everyone is trying to leave those country. They're to worried about keeping the people they have.
_________________________
I do custom myspace pages! Check out my work http://www.myspace.com/naomisuemontgomery and http://www.myspace.com/nashvilleapril email me at nmontgomery1984@yahoo.com for mor info or message me on JPF!

Top
#751562 - 09/12/09 02:23 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: NaomiSue]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
The wonderful thing, and sometimes not so wonderful, about our constitution is how it provided a framework for our democratic republic to build on.
It ain't perfect but it comes close.
This is an example.
Back in those days people were still getting off the boat looking for a better life. It wasn't until later the issue of citizenship really became a problem. That's when they wrote the 14th amendment in 1866.
Even then it wasn't clear. Still isn't as is evidenced by the anchor baby debate.

Personally I do not believe any person in this country illegally should get any constitutional rights or citizenship. Including unborn children.
I think the baby is an illegal immigrant when it is in the womb and an illegal immigrant when it leaves the womb.
Unborn fetuses are protected by laws. They should also be subject to laws.
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#751583 - 09/12/09 05:48 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
Gary Gray X



Registered: 12/16/07
Posts: 2461
Loc: TEXAS
it seems to me that if the person is here on USA soil illegally that anything they have with them or "in them" is also here illegally but that's my interpetation of the law, like if they had swallowed a balloon of drugs those drugs would be here illegally too so for that reasoning of it the uborn fetus or if you want to call it a child is here illegally and should be subject to the same laws of immigration as the mother.I know some of you bleeding hearts are gonna dispute this but that's to be expected too.I mean those same bleeding hearts don't believe in the death penalty but if it was a member of your family or friend that got mudered you'd be the 1st in line to want to pull the switch on that rascal too that committed the crime .
Top
#751622 - 09/12/09 08:30 PM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Gary Gray X]
Scott Campbell
Top 10 Poster


Registered: 07/22/05
Posts: 10861
Loc: Lakeland, FL, USA
Originally Posted By: Gary D. Gray
I know some of you bleeding hearts are gonna dispute this but that's to be expected too.I mean those same bleeding hearts don't believe in the death penalty but if it was a member of your family or friend that got mudered you'd be the 1st in line to want to pull the switch on that rascal too that committed the crime .


Well,

(1) It costs more to execute people than it does to lock them up without parole for the rest of their lives.

(2) It frequently is applied to people who didn't commit the crime.

(3) It is not a deterrent.

Other than that, it's OK I suppose..... \:D

Scott

Top
#751644 - 09/13/09 12:05 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Scott Campbell]
Bill Robinson
Top 100 Poster


Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 6190
Loc: Curmudgeonville, Tn
Quote:
(1) It costs more to execute people than it does to lock them up without parole for the rest of their lives.

Only because they put them on death row where the guard to prisoner ratio is low and they get unlimited appeals for years. Tying up countless hours of judicial time. If they would actually execute the scum in a timely manner it would cost about $2.00. The cost of one bullet.

Quote:
(2) It frequently is applied to people who didn't commit the crime.
really? Some verifiable stats please? Because I seriously doubt it and more than likely the scum probably committed another crime just as bad.
There have been about 16,000 executions in 400 years with just over 100 exonerated on death row and about 25 after execution.. I wouldn't call that "frequently"
The 100 exonerated on appeal shows the system does work even if poorly, there is an appeal process unfortunately it gets abused.. The 25 who were exonerated after the execution are unfortunate. But I bet most were bad guys anyway.

Quote:
(3) It is not a deterrent.

What difference does that make. Putting people in jail doesn't stop people from stealing. Maybe we should do away with jails.
Voting out Politicians for being idiots and liars don't stop them from being idiots and liars. Maybe we should just stop voting. \:\)

Actually I think with DNA testing and improved forensics we have today it would be more likely to be certain of the conviction.


Edited by Bill Robinson (09/13/09 12:15 AM)
_________________________
Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/

Top
#751648 - 09/13/09 12:50 AM Re: President Obama might get Health Care right! [Re: Bill Robinson]
Scott Campbell
Top 10 Poster


Registered: 07/22/05
Posts: 10861
Loc: Lakeland, FL, USA
LOL - I was going to give some statistics I found but they seem to be in agreement with yours. Guess we'll have to disagree on "frequently". I wouldn't say that I was a good shot "frequently" if I only made 25 baskets out of 16000. But I'd sure as hell use it if I put 25 people to death for a crime they didn't commit.

And the number of exonerations is just downright frightening to me - and they are becoming more prevalent with DNA testing. 135 people exonerated since 1973.

Which means the number of wrongful executions would skyrocket if we started moving faster - as you advocate in your response to (1).

My objection to the death penalty is not based on a "sanctity of human life" argument. It's based on the notion that you can't take it back if you are wrong. And the number of exonerations represent about 1% of the total. One percent error is a huge number when you're talking about putting someone to death!

The reason I brought up deterrence is that many use this an an argument for why the death penalty should be applied. Saying that it isn't is not the same thing as saying we should let killers go free.

By using life imprisonment with no hope of parole, we protect society and spend less money than by applying the death penalty. And we allow for the possibility (which even a statistician would call significant) that they didn't commit the crime.

Why is this not a good idea?

Scott


Edited by Scott Campbell (09/13/09 12:53 AM)

Top
Page 1 of 2 12>


Moderator:  Andrew Aversa 
Hop to:
Community Partners
Support Just Plain Folks

We would like to keep the membership in Just Plain Folks FREE! Your donation helps support the many programs we offer including Road Trips and the Music Awards.


Membership
Join Just Plain Folks
to receive the free
JPNotes Newsletter!
*this is separate from
message board registration*

Newest Members
dhanushu, elderiessew, Scotty, ElatteMed, former client
19787 Registered Users
Forum Stats
19787 Members
120 Forums
101416 Topics
942854 Posts

Max Online: 1456 @ 04/10/08 05:00 PM

Generated in 0.108 seconds in which 0.01 seconds were spent on a total of 14 queries. Zlib compression enabled.