Yeah they have some that are on there who actually know alot about music not just random people. and they use it to promote themselves as a critic...which everyone is... but when I see an 18 year old black kid who listen to rap being asked to listen to an early 70s song by ANYONE, let alone a rock singer, I'm pretty sure they haven't heard it before . if I had a channel like that, I guarantee I wouldn't know 99% of ANY rap song or a good majority of songs released even this year.

But the glaring weakness is nobody is going to say something sucks, even if they think it does. a good chance they will never listen to those songs again.

I have seen one guy who hates everything and rips it and is funny doing it.

At the end of the day its to draw traffic to your channel.